The Goods Buying Guide

Wool vs. Jute Rugs: Which One Should You Buy?

Wool is softer and forgives spills. Jute has more texture and costs less, but it hates water. How to choose between them, room by room.

4 minute readby upstate down

A hand knotted jute Mojave rug in Cashew in a quiet room with an armchair

the goods

The short answer

Buy wool for rooms where you sit on the floor, spill things or want softness. Buy jute for texture in a dry room where a lower price matters. If you want some of both, buy a blend.

Wool and jute are the two fibers most of our rugs are made from, and people often arrive torn between them. They look related in photos. They behave very differently at home. Here is the plain comparison of wool vs. jute rugs.

The quick comparison

Wool Jute
Feel Soft, with some spring Firm and textured, a little coarse on bare feet
Spills Gives you time to blot Water can leave a brown mark
Shedding Sheds when new, then settles Drops some fiber and dust underneath
Price Higher Lower
Best rooms Living rooms, bedrooms, family rooms Dry living rooms, studies, dining rooms, layered under another rug
Avoid Strong direct sun all day Bathrooms, mudrooms, damp basements, covered porches

What wool does well

Wool fibers have a natural crimp, so they spring back after a chair leg or a footstep. That is why a wool rug still looks good after years in the middle of a living room. The fiber also carries a little natural oil, which buys you a few minutes to blot a spill before it sinks in.

The tradeoffs are price and shedding. A new wool rug sheds loose fiber left over from making it. It is normal, it fades over time, and regular vacuuming without a beater bar gets you through it. Thick, chunky wool sheds for longer than a tight flat weave.

What jute does well

Jute is a plant fiber, spun from the stalk. It has a dry, matte, woven look that wool cannot copy, and its natural color sits easily with wood, stone and plaster. It also costs less. In our shop, custom sizes in the jute flat weaves start at a lower rate per square foot than any of the wool rugs.

The tradeoff is water. When jute gets wet it releases oils that turn the fiber brown, and it holds moisture long enough to mildew. So a spilled glass of water can leave a mark that was not there before, and wet cleaning is out. Keep jute in dry rooms, blot spills right away with a dry cloth, and do not let anyone steam clean it.

Worth knowing

Jute is firm, not soft. If small children play on the floor or you like to sit on the rug, you will be happier with wool or a blend.

The middle option: a blend

A rug that weaves wool and jute together gets some of each. The jute brings texture and keeps the price down. The wool softens the hand and helps the rug wear. Blends are still natural fiber rugs, so the dry room rule still applies.

How to choose by room

  • Living room you use every day: wool, or a blend if you want more texture.
  • Bedroom: wool. Your feet land on it first thing in the morning.
  • Dining room: a flat weave in either fiber so chairs slide. Choose wool if red wine is a regular guest.
  • Study or a quiet sitting room: jute is a good fit here.
  • Anywhere damp: neither. Natural fiber rugs need to stay dry.

One of each, from the shop

Tempest wool rug in Tundra in a living room

Tempest Rug

Wool. A flat weave made by hand from undyed New Zealand wool. Undyed means the color is the color of the fleece, so there is no dye to fade.

See it in the shop →

Mojave jute rug in Natural under a wooden desk and chair

Mojave Rug

Jute. Most jute rugs are flat. This one is hand knotted into a loop pile from handspun yarn, so it has more depth underfoot than you expect from jute.

See it in the shop →

Willow rug in Cumin beside a low bed

Willow Rug

The blend. Wool and jute woven over a linen warp, with a low profile that is easy to live with in a bedroom or under a table.

See it in the shop →

All three are by Armadillo and are made to order in standard and custom sizes. Rugs are final sale, so if you are unsure about the feel, come and stand on a few of our rugs in Rhinebeck first.

in the shop Armadillo
shop all Armadillo